What does Sarah Palin have against women who were raped?
Just a weird observation. We all know about Palin's efforts in Wasilla to make women pay for their own rape evidence kits, an effort that eventually led to a law being passed in the Alaska legislature specifically to stop Palin because the policy was considered so wrong.
Next we have Palin's abortion stance. Roughly, it doesn't matter if you were raped, you have to have the baby. (I always have trouble with the "Being raped is god's will" argument.)
Tonight, I come across this in the McCain campaign's efforts to explain away the "Troopergate" firing of Public Safety Commisioner Walt Monegan.
I know this this is a very tenuous case, and may be a wildly inappropriate figment of my imagination, but it does seem like, time and again, Palin seems to side against rape victims. (A seeming consistent policy of "pull yourself up by your own bootstraps, ladies" "Don't look to the state for help," and "God wanted it this way.") I'll leave the psychological interpolation to y'all.
And, no, this isn't sexist. If it were a man who time and again sided against rape victims, it would be significantly creepy as well.
Alaska has the highest incidence of rape in the country.
(Kind of a late night post. It may seem very wrong tomorrow. If you think this is wildly inappropriate, I'll apologize in advance.)
Next we have Palin's abortion stance. Roughly, it doesn't matter if you were raped, you have to have the baby. (I always have trouble with the "Being raped is god's will" argument.)
Tonight, I come across this in the McCain campaign's efforts to explain away the "Troopergate" firing of Public Safety Commisioner Walt Monegan.
To that end, the campaign released a series of e-mails detailing the frustration several Palin administration officials experienced in dealing with Monegan. The "last straw," the campaign said, was a trip Monegan planned to Washington in July to seek federal money for investigating and prosecuting sexual assault cases.
I know this this is a very tenuous case, and may be a wildly inappropriate figment of my imagination, but it does seem like, time and again, Palin seems to side against rape victims. (A seeming consistent policy of "pull yourself up by your own bootstraps, ladies" "Don't look to the state for help," and "God wanted it this way.") I'll leave the psychological interpolation to y'all.
And, no, this isn't sexist. If it were a man who time and again sided against rape victims, it would be significantly creepy as well.
Alaska has the highest incidence of rape in the country.
(Kind of a late night post. It may seem very wrong tomorrow. If you think this is wildly inappropriate, I'll apologize in advance.)
4 Comments:
Armchair psychologist...
It could be her socio-religious upbringing and world view that denies the idea of rape; that boys will be boys and it's a woman's responsibility to not encourage them. This would be somewhat similar to the other fringe denials of evolution, climate change and gender equality.
Another possibility is that she has some personal sexual issues. Perhaps she was raped (date rape). Maybe a man close to her was accused of rape (Todd? Daddy?). Either of these -- coupled with a tendency of denial and the shameless ability to fabricate a reality out of whole-cloth (i.e. lie) -- would explain her passive-aggressive hostility toward victims of sexual assault.
The third possibility is that she's just an asshole. But I'm just guessing here.
By -epm, at 8:09 AM
Mike, I've been in the pro-life movement for 20+ years and have never heard anyone say rape is God's will. Where do you get this? It must be someone on the lunatic fringe.
The more mainstream view is that rape is a terrible crime that should be severely punished. However, the one to punish is the rapist - not the innocent child who was conceived as a result of the crime. We should not punish children for the offenses of their father.
It is true that we as a society could do a lot more to help women in this situation get through the pregnancy and then, if they choose, give up the child for adoption. That's another issue.
As for the rape kits and funding, I agree it seems strange. It would be nice to hear an explanation.
By Patrick, at 8:19 AM
Palin's explanation for not paying for rape kits, and for opposing seeking federal funding to investigate sexual assault crimes, is clear. Sexual assault and its victims were simply not an issue she cared to spend time and money on. Zero. She would a) rather not spend the money at all b) rather spend the money elsewhere and c) it interfered with her political relationship with Sen. Stevens. These are the explanations issued either by her and/or her staff.
The issues of funding rape kits and the investigation and prosecution of sexual assault crimes has nothing to do with the abortion issue. Putting aside the abortion issue, her (budgetary and policy) hostility toward victims of sexual assault is a shocking to the conscience.
By -epm, at 8:42 AM
EPM, I have no idea on the psychology, I just wanted to put it out there.
As for your second point, yeah, there seems to be a pattern of hostility there.
....
Patrick. Yeah, I overstated it, but that's how that position often comes across to those of us who are non-religious.
Frankly, I don't have a real problem with the pro-life position in principle, but the rape case isn't quite as simple as you present it. Having that child provides a link for the mother forever to what was likely the very worst moment of her life. Even if she puts it up for adoption, she still has to go through the pregnancy which is 9 months of living a reminder of the act.
As for God's will. If you believe life begins at conception on a scientific basis, and that's it, I get your point.
BUT, if your principle that abortion is wrong because god creates every life individually, then you get into the logical position that god created that life, hence made that rape. See what I'm saying?
I don't really want to fight, because nobody ever convinces anybody on this issue. This response is just to explain my position.
By mikevotes, at 2:25 PM
Post a Comment
<< Home