.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Born at the Crest of the Empire

Wednesday, April 18, 2007

Assuming the primaries were held today....

As you look at all the polling on the '08 candidates and on specific issues like Iraq, keep this in mind: With the current political situation, independents will likely be voting exclusively in the Democratic primaries.

So, when you talk about a McCain and his untenable prowar position, remember that in a Republican primary without independents, you get Iraq polling like this,
Among Republicans, 76 percent said it was the right thing to do and 20 percent said the U.S. should have stayed out.....

Among just Republicans, 62 percent thought the war was going very or somewhat well, compared to 36 percent who said somewhat or very badly.....

Among Republicans, 72 percent said success is very or somewhat likely,

Also, you have to figure the pro war folks are about the deepest of the koolaid drinkers, so they will probably overrepresent from this polling in the primaries.

Now, it's a long way between here and there, and I would expect further erosion, but if you look at Republican primaries without any independents, pro Iraq war is still a very winning Republican position. (Of course that would leave a Dole-like candidate for the general election.)

I don't have as good a sense of what this would mean on the Democratic side. Does it make the overall primary base more centrist, or, because these independents have come over for the war, does it make the antiwar position ascendent?

(I've said it before, I'm really beginning to think that this is the new McCain primary strategy.)

3 Comments:

  • Those are pretty discouraging stats, even for republicans.

    If I was a salesman, I'd sure love to have a mailing list with those names on it.

    By Anonymous Anonymous, at 10:26 PM  

  • I think you are right about this strategy, and actually it doesn't look that dumb, at least for the primary.

    The Economist continues to say that he is going to make a comeback before this is over. You can get over 5 to 1 odds for McCain to win the primary on Intrade. At the beginning of the year it was less than 2 to 1.

    Right now wouldn't be a bad time to lay down some money. The $1 contract has just recently bumped from 18.1 cents to 19.8. Still good odds and I suppose he will continue to climb on this "market controled probability index" as I call it.

    By Blogger Praguetwin, at 5:04 AM  

  • abi, oh yeah. That's the kind of denial that can certainly be exploited.

    Karl Rove, Pat Robertson, and Fox News do have that list.

    ...

    Praguetwin, I think he got outflanked on the "maverick"/outsider by Giuliani, so, seeing the probush/prowar space he's turning back.

    I'm not completely sure the strategy will work, though. Even assuming he can successfully stake out that population, it will still dwindle somewhat over the next year.

    Those people have unbelievebly stuck with Bush through everything, but I'm not going to bet on Bush or the war getting more popular.

    So, this strategy would be a race.

    Oh, and again, it will get McCain slaughtered in the general, because that's going to be an impossible pivot.

    By Blogger mikevotes, at 7:12 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home